Avenged Sevenfold have released an important statement regarding Mike Portnoys departure and more to fans.
For the past few months, we’ve been blessed with Mike Portnoy’s talent and humanity. When Mike agreed to tour with us, it was only through the end of 2010. We always knew we’d need to find another solution for 2011 and beyond. And it’s time for us to take that next step.
We know we are not ready to add another permanent member of Avenged Sevenfold. We don’t know if we will ever be. But if we do, it will only be with someone who is not only a brilliant drummer, but also someone we’ve gotten to know well on the road and off, and who you the fans have had a chance to get to know, and hopefully accept. In other words, in this family, we take these steps together, band and our extended fan family.
We are lucky to be surrounded by so many friends, many of whom knew Jimmy very well personally, as well as our band and Jimmy’s drumming talent and style. These friends have introduced us to several amazing drummers. We have decided to take one of them out starting in January. He will not be a member of a7x. He will be someone you and we are getting to know. Perhaps this drummer will be a fit. Perhaps not. One thing is for sure. Over time we will find someone who helps us continue our quest to make the music we love for the fans we love.
Mike and the band agree that can’t be him. Why? Long before there was an Avenged Sevenfold, there were members of this band who looked up to Mike and, in Jimmy’s case, learned a lot from watching Mike play. He is a brilliant writer, producer and of course drummer. Because of that, the world and we would always see it as Avenged Sevenfold with Mike Portnoy. We take a lot of pride in A7X being about something greater then any individuals. Its about the music, the fans and the friends and family we have as well as continuing our best friends legacy.
Please give whoever we try your love and support….and the benefit of the doubt. They won’t be Jimmy. Who could be? But he will be himself, with his own special talents and creativity. And that’s all we could ever look for.
Thank you again from the bottom of our hearts for everything you’ve done to love and support us.
A7X
Like this:
239 Comments so far
Leave a comment
Supporting them no matter what <3
Comment by Brianna (brianna7x) December 17, 2010 @ 12:24 pmExactly what I thought. Exactly. Whoever it is, they’re gonna be included in a wonderful family, and welcomed no matter what. Of course it wont be as it was with Jimmy, we know that, but whoever A7X see as good enough, I’ll happily welcome. See you at download A7X :’)
Comment by EmilyVengeance December 17, 2010 @ 12:43 pm♥
Yep. Haven’t made a mistake yet. I fully believe in them!
Comment by Nolan December 17, 2010 @ 2:39 pmsame here :D! i support a7x no matter what!
Comment by amy December 17, 2010 @ 2:50 pmSame here. I have their backs!
Comment by Carol December 18, 2010 @ 4:30 amThis is good news, and a great statement. :o)
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 12:26 pmhey whatever you guys do, imma support ya :) good luck to the newbie, im sure theyll fit in just fine :)
Comment by Hannah B December 17, 2010 @ 12:27 pmWow! a bit sad for Mike. he seemed like he really wanted this. however, I’m really happy for my own selfish reasons. I’m glad our boys will continue on as a band and I hope whenever they do find their “new” member, he can be atleast a tad bit as amazing as Jimmy was. he’ll never be Jimmy, but I can’t wait to see who it’s gonna be =)
Comment by LittleMissRESENTMENT December 17, 2010 @ 12:28 pmThe reasoning they gave for splitting with Mike makes a lot of sense. I didn’t realize how much I said Avenged Sevenfold with Mike Portnoy when I talked about them with my friends. I’m really excited to see who they choose as their full-time drummer, especially when it comes time for them to record something new.
Comment by Chris December 17, 2010 @ 12:28 pmsame here. it was always “the boys and Mike”
Comment by wench December 17, 2010 @ 12:54 pmI’m very excited to see who they have lined up! This interview clears up a lot. Thanks MP for all that u have done. A7X foREVer!
Comment by Brad December 17, 2010 @ 12:29 pmfoREVer <3
Comment by phill taylor December 17, 2010 @ 12:29 pmVery interesting. I’ll look forward to see who this mystery drummer is.
Comment by bre December 17, 2010 @ 12:31 pmok maybe Im strange but reading that made me tear up. i have so much love and respect for this band, I cant imagine they would pick anyone to play with them that I wouldnt approve of. And I think this decision makes a lot of sense.
Comment by Bianca December 17, 2010 @ 12:32 pmYou’re not strange! It made me feel really emotional as well. I think it was just a really powerful statement, somehow.
Comment by Rachel December 17, 2010 @ 12:35 pmIt is powerful. This statement wasn’t about Mike leaving, it was about a new drummer. And, maybe, the future of the band.(That’s what I felt. It was a huge ‘wow’ for me. I got emotional.)
Comment by Rocky December 17, 2010 @ 3:33 pmyeah me too…….felt really sad after reading that
Comment by mcra7xbfmv December 17, 2010 @ 12:38 pmfemales eh pffffft lol
Comment by John December 17, 2010 @ 1:18 pmYeah I got emotional too.
Comment by Rocky December 17, 2010 @ 3:30 pmI teared… It was hard for me to read this….
Comment by Neal December 18, 2010 @ 7:04 pmI’m glad they are continuing, and trying to find a new, hopefully permanent drummer. I’m going to see them on their first show of the new year (January 20) and I can’t wait to see who they chose. They have my full support :)
Comment by Cierra December 17, 2010 @ 12:32 pmI’m really looking foward to see the guys again at Download. You have all our support, you’ll always have it :)
Comment by Nickie December 17, 2010 @ 12:33 pmI love these guys again and again, whatever they do. I love everything they do.:)
Comment by lean99zz December 17, 2010 @ 12:38 pmsad, yet exciting.
Comment by (; December 17, 2010 @ 12:41 pmwhatever you do i’ll support you no matter what as im sure other fans will
Comment by toria7x December 17, 2010 @ 12:45 pmA7X foREVer <3
Yea, I always said A7X with Mike… Whoever they get will have my respect… I honor the decision that has been made. I’m glad to hear they are thinking about continuing, even though its never gonna be easy without the Rev behind their backs on the drums. The truth be told that he will always be there drumming along and singing the melodies. We just have to listen closely. :D
Comment by Jessica December 17, 2010 @ 12:47 pmAs if their message wasn’t good enough, the end of yours has just made my day ^^ Haha, so true :)
Comment by SS December 17, 2010 @ 1:14 pmI completely agree with you especially your last statement. :) A7X foREVer!
Comment by Ghostflame83 December 17, 2010 @ 3:20 pmThanks..
Comment by Jessica December 18, 2010 @ 10:35 amI have loved a7x since the beginning.. since i was a kid – and meeting syn and watching a7x live has been amazing. if the music lieson then its great.. jimmy lives on with all of us he is in us all.. that twisited awesome that we all love..that eclectic amazingness is in all a7x fans.. i hope this new guy brings it but in all seriousness i love avenged sevenfold and i hope they make record breaking music like usual as i want to see the reborn A7X as it would be both a great tribute and a great vengeance to see a7x +1 take on the world once again – a loyal and devoted fan – Chris!
Comment by Chris c December 17, 2010 @ 12:48 pmCan someone pass the tissues ? Awesome statement but still upsetting over Jimmy
The guys know we’re 100% behind them every step of the way of course we don’t want someone to go in and totally replace Jimmy – he can never be replaced – as Mike did just need someone to keep Jimmy’s spirit alive so we all know that although he’s not there he is in the way his music is being played
28th Dec is going to be a day I wish wasn’t happening
FoREVer loved FoREVer missed
Comment by sarra December 17, 2010 @ 12:49 pmgreat statement. actually made my weekend alot better. i read dbn pretty much everyday & all this news about mike leaving & people bein upset, pissed off & confused was bringin me down. a7x will always be my number 1 band. theyre the only band i would tattoo on me, which i did. i have a deathbat & “FoREVer” recently got added right under it. they mean the world to me & im so glad to hear they want to continue the search for a drummer to bring into The Family!!!! stay strong guys :)
Comment by dani December 17, 2010 @ 12:53 pm<3
foREVer C:
Comment by Loghen December 17, 2010 @ 12:55 pmJust a question: They have someone lined up, and that someone will be a touring member with the possibility of becoming a permanent one?
correct but i dont think their really viewing this as a tryout. i dont think they have reached that stage emotionally yet.
Comment by Mark December 17, 2010 @ 4:30 pmI really feel bad for Portnoy… It’s clear his intention was to at least remain with the band for 2011 and they felt differently. The statement says both sides agreed that he couldn’t be permanent but there’s clearly more to it than that if you read what he’s said himself the past week. There were articles with him saying he would be the drummer throughout 2011 as well.. He said he didn’t quit DT for A7X and I believe A7X didn’t know about it, but Mike’s intentions to stay with the band a little longer had to have something to do with it.
Comment by CC December 17, 2010 @ 12:56 pmYep, I think that is why I personally feel very bad. Besides Mikes talent behind the drums, he seemed like a great person. It looked like he had loads of fun with the band and I think Portnoy expected to stay with them for a little while longer, but the band had other ideas. I can’t imagine being in that situation. One day you’re feeling great,expecting to continue on having a blast w/ the band into the next year and then breaking the news to him that they are moving on without him :(. I can only imagine how crushed he must of been, hence the “Sad” tweet earlier in the week.
I guess both sides will just have to move on. I’m looking forward to the future of the band, and I will always respect portnoy and remain a fan of his.
Comment by Sean December 17, 2010 @ 3:41 pmWe’ll support avenged no matter what, because that’s what family does. <3
Comment by Carriebelle. December 17, 2010 @ 1:00 pmI hope the next guy is more of a member then just a drummer. Best of luck A7X. You guys have been through so much. Ill be out there supporting you guys no matter what already got the tickets. A7X 4 life!
Comment by Maria December 17, 2010 @ 1:05 pmthis is gonna get interesting..
Comment by reppin the 734 December 17, 2010 @ 1:05 pmWhen i went to go see them in Toronto, there where eight of us.
1 of them was going just to see Mike. They got in to A7X after, but now i think about it,i get what the band means when they say this,
They have always been for the fans, not as individuals, but together and its amazing. I truly have the utmost respect for these guys and it continues to grow. The attention they give to us fans, in making sure we are with them and understanding them, again is unbelievable.
The family we have here is in incredible, and i thank them for this.
=D
Comment by Julia December 17, 2010 @ 1:06 pmYou guys are the best. :)
So true to yourselves, your band, your music, and even your fans. You guys know what’s best, how could anyone doubt that?
Anything you guys do – I will honor and respect because you always stay true to who you are and what you do.
I can’t wait to see you amazing, talented men on Jan. 22nd-and I look forward to getting to know whoever then new man behind the drums will be. :)
foRever<3
Comment by Rachael December 17, 2010 @ 1:06 pmI can’t even begin to imagine how hard this is for the guys. All of this going on so close to the day. Whatever they do, I will definitely be behind them 100%.
Comment by ashleigh December 17, 2010 @ 1:07 pmThe maturity level of the boys is untouchable!
I’ve been an MP/DT fan since I got their first cassette, my senior year of High School, in 1989. After Jimmy’s death my friend asked who should fill in and my first answer, without thought, was Mike. My friend laughed at that… Some dreams do come true (Please don’t accuse me of being happy that Jimmy left us so that Mike could play with them…)!
When I first heard Avenged I couldn’t believe that “MY Metal” had finally come back and these crazy kids from OC were running full force with the Metal Flag. What an awesome representation of the greatest genre in music they were/are. And I had found a new favorite drummer in the process; especially after seein the MVI from the Self Titled.
With all my excitement that MP would be the man to fill in, I now realize, as Matt stated, that I said a lot of A7X + MP. I am ecstatic that have chosen to move forward in the manner that is stated above!!! This will truly bring a new member into the Family and allow that person to grow with a well established and well loved band.
Although I am sad to see Mike’s tour and professional relationship with Avenged end, I can’t wait to Welcome in the person that Johnny, Matt, Syn, and Zacky feel could become a lifelong brother.
As a soon to be 39 year old male, I have to say that I love these guys with all my heart! When I was lucky enough to meet them, including Val, at the Slidebar for the Nightmare celebration I have to say that I don’t have “friends” that treated me as well as these complete strangers did (Unfortunately I didn’t get to meet Johnny)! It is a testament to the character and respect they have for humanity in general.
Long live Avenged Sevenfold, foREVer actually, and may they continue to see the world as they do. I know that I am forever in their debt for the music they create and the sincerity of what they say through their lyrics.
fat
Comment by fatboy December 17, 2010 @ 1:10 pmVery well said. I’m soon to be 32 and feel the exact same way. Avenged Sevenfold quickly became my favorite band after I was exposed to their music for the first time 5 plus years ago.
The more I’ve learned about the band, the more my love for their talents grew.
Comment by Dave December 17, 2010 @ 2:24 pmi’m 11
Comment by Anonymous December 18, 2010 @ 9:31 amThis made me smile… Then cry a little bit, haha! Beautiful words and pretty much exactly what I’d hoped :) My love for this band has only gotten stronger over the years and things like this are precisely why they mean so much to me. Good luck to them and I hope something works out for them- they deserve it so much!
Comment by SS December 17, 2010 @ 1:12 pmA7X foREVer
I love every statement they make, for real!
Comment by Rachel December 17, 2010 @ 1:12 pmI can’t tell how much love and respect I have for this band. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a band that cares so much for their fans like Avenged do.
I do agree with them with the “Avenged Sevenfold with Mike Portnoy” part and I understand why they made the decision of continuing without him.
Regarding the new drummer thing, I don’t think I’m ready for a new one, but with what they told us, I’m sure all the A7X family will accept him, even though he won’t be Jimmy.
A7X has my support no matter what! I love that this band is about not only the members but the fans as well and not individual egos as a whole. How many other bands can say that? They want whoever to have their own artistic flair and creativity. Gives me hope that they will continue as a band. Jimmy is with them guiding them to do the right thing. foREVer in my heart and mind, I love you Jimmy and the rest of the band. I’m willing to give whoever a chance.
Comment by Sian December 17, 2010 @ 1:15 pmAs unhappy as this makes me, i am also that little bit relieved. I love a7x and i’m so glad that i finally got to see them on this tour. Mike totally slayed every night. A true professional and gentleman.
What saddens me is that i hadn’t seen portnoy this happy and motivated in years. He looked like he was having so much fun with a7x.
I was completely devastated when Mike left Dream Theater and i can only hope that now this is over he can take some time out, work things out with DT and return to his rightful place.
As much as i hate to say it Mike Portnoy has way too much talent/skill to waste on a straight forward metal/rock act. The Rev was truely amazing but he ain’t no Mike Portnoy.
Mike you are the man and no doubt i’ll be seeing you back in action soon!!
Comment by John December 17, 2010 @ 1:20 pmI can’t wait to see A7X for the seventh time and I really looking forward to Cincinnati. We, the fans, don’t see the personal aspects of the music business, but we sure love the music and are behind the A7X team 110%.
Comment by Tracey7777 December 17, 2010 @ 1:20 pmNo doubt, being a fan you stand by the band. But as a fan of both sides, I’m pissed. After Jimmy, this was the next best pairing.
Comment by Pete December 17, 2010 @ 1:27 pmIt sounds like an ego driven thing. Perhaps they couldn’t or didn’t want to handle a star the size of Portnoy.
or u know, they could have released him for the exact reason they stated in their statement.. has nothing to do with ego. it’s THEIR BAND which means THEY can make the choices that THEY want to and shouldnt be reprimanded for it just because people like u dont like it.
Comment by hunter December 17, 2010 @ 3:35 pmHope it’s a badass drummer
Comment by Chris December 17, 2010 @ 1:47 pmcouldnt of said it better myself
Comment by eh7x December 17, 2010 @ 10:32 pmA HUGE thank you to Mike Portnoy for helping A7X through what has been an extremely difficult process. Also, thanks to the guys in the band for releasing this statement which clears things up a bit.
I’ll support whoever the drummer may be and the Rev’s legacy will continue to live through the music.
See you guys in Cincinnati! Thank you for being YOU.
Comment by Dave December 17, 2010 @ 2:07 pmBehind you all the way guys :)
Comment by Harley Quinn December 17, 2010 @ 2:13 pmCan’t wait to see them in January, especially, with the new guy/gal.
rock on A7X!
Comment by gab December 17, 2010 @ 2:17 pmI Love Avenged & I Will Definately Support Their Decision.I Have Been A Fan For Almost 6 Years, And Never Have I Seen A Band With Fans Who Treat Each Other Like A Family, & After Jimmy’s Passing, We All Grieved As A Family. I Love What The Guys Have Done For Us, Especially During The Hard Times. When Mike Came In, I Admit, I Was Skeptical About How Things Were Gonna Work Out. I Admire Mike For Doing This For Us The Fans, And I Will Miss Mike In A7X. But I Guess This Was Gonna Happen Sooner Or Later. But No Matter What, Avenged Is Gonna Have The Support Of All The Fans. This Statement Truly Hit My Heart, But I Know They Do Things For A Reason. Thanks Guys For Doing Everything For Us The Fans. foREVer A Fan<3
Comment by Manny December 17, 2010 @ 2:17 pm…yeah i agree with them…but still…Mike seemed like he really wanted to stay a part of A7X. Even though they said he agreed on him not being that good for their official drummer, i think they are being kind of harsh on Mike just so they can find a new drummer. I kinda feel like they wanted to make him go back in Dream Theater so they said it wouldnt be a good idea for him to carry on with a7x. I am not being disrespectful to them or the fans so please dont start saying im an idiot. im just posting my opinion as is everyone else on here…
Comment by Anonymous December 17, 2010 @ 2:20 pmI see all of these comments about Avenged Sevenfold & Mike Portnoy… I only referred to them as that because that’s what they were; Mike wasn’t part of the band.
Comment by Mike December 17, 2010 @ 2:22 pmAgreed. If Mike had ever joined on a more permanent basis I would have just called them “Avenged Sevenfold”. No matter what the reason is, it must not have been as good of a fit as many of us thought it was. If the members aren’t comfortable with continuing on with him then there is no way to change that.
Looking forward to the future of A7X. Just a bit bummed for Mike because he really seemed like he wanted to stick with the band , but I guess its time for him and the band to move on. I’ll always respect Mike for what he did with A7X and I’ll always be a fan of his.
So I’m kinda happy but sad at the same time :P. Happy to know A7X will continue (though I think many of us expected that), sad that MP will no longer be with A7X :(
Comment by Anonymous December 17, 2010 @ 3:26 pmI completely agree. Mike wasn’t a member so of course he was going to be referred to by his name and not just Avenged Sevenfold since he wasn’t really part of Avenged Sevenfold. If he had been a member, I’m sure that would have continued on for a while, but not forever.
Comment by Anonymous December 17, 2010 @ 3:53 pmWe will support you no matter what:)
Comment by Angst December 17, 2010 @ 2:33 pmA7x foREVer XD
Cincy tickets going fast. Just checked to pick some up for a friend and all that is left are upper level. Floor, lower level and upper level- center are history. Great to see!
Comment by Ryan December 17, 2010 @ 2:34 pmCan´t wait to see who will be the new guy.
Comment by RuiA7X December 17, 2010 @ 2:35 pmIt’s funny how I never said or thought of “A7X with Mike Portnoy”. I always thought he was part of the family from the moment he stepped in the studio to help record Nightmare.
Comment by Gabby7x December 17, 2010 @ 2:50 pmme too! without mike we wouldnt have the album released! thanks mike but im anxious to see the new guy too
Comment by jruss December 17, 2010 @ 3:36 pmYep, I felt he was part of the family as well. I guess he still is, just not in the way I thought he would be. I guess that’s my fault for expecting him to become something more in A7X then he was.
I disagree with A7X’s message in that they will be overshadowed by MP (that’s the message I was getting from them anyways), but I guess it’s not my position to disagree with them. I can’t change the way they feel.
Still, I’m happy for A7X and I’m looking forward to the bands future.
Comment by Sean December 17, 2010 @ 3:57 pmMe too, lotta ppl did tho.
Comment by mike December 17, 2010 @ 4:37 pmI dont know who the will be behind the kit, but whoever it is, i trust A7X’s judgements and they will be welcomed into our beautiful family with open arms :)
Comment by H December 17, 2010 @ 3:02 pmI am glad Mike was able to help them in 2010, I’m sure whoever they bring along for 2011 will be a great candidate.. Looking forward to hearing the update on who it will be!! Jimmy is happy and proud of you guys no matter who you pick! foREVer!!!
Comment by Michelle H. December 17, 2010 @ 3:14 pmStill digesting it …
Comment by EnchantedW. December 17, 2010 @ 3:44 pmWhat the hell was than every night with ”welcome to the family mr. Portnoy” … double-faced game?! Now you’re saying he was never one of us, just 1+ …
And than this: Portnoy, you’re overskilled to contribute to the band?! On one hand they want versatile contribution from new drummer, on the other they don’t. Make up your minds, boys!
I respect Sullivan, it was a tragedy (although I have zero tollerance to drugs)but let him rest. Even if you lose your parents or child, you don’t mention it every day in every situation. One has to move on. And it seems to me this playing around with the new guy behind the drums isn’t fair. Like, maybe in 10 years you’ll be one of us, till then you’re exspendable. Not nice at all.
I think you’re misunderstanding. I don’t think them saying welcome to the family has now turned into him not being one of us. When he joined them on tour it was a a temporary gig, he was welcomed into the family just as all of us are a part of the family, but it seems to them it was always Avenged with Mike and this was what was going to happen. I also don’t think they’re saying he’s over-skilled, but I think they’re saying that he’s got his own thing, his own renown, his own goals and aspirations that aren’t hand in hand with Avenged’s. I think they’re saying that his outlook on the music and theirs aren’t in harmony for him to become a permanent member of the band. I think what they’re looking for is someone to add to the band, but as part of Avenged with the same goals and view points, and Mike just might not be that for them.
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 5:55 pmI also think you’re off regarding ‘playing around with the new guy behind the drums.’ I don’t think they’re playing, I think they’re being open and honest from the start, anyone that they bring in is going to know the situation from the beginning. The guys may never have a permanent replacement for Jimmy, they may have people sit on the kit without ever becoming a full-blown Avenged member. Its been stated, its already out there, so anyone who takes up the sticks is going to have that knowledge when they agree to take up the kit. I think the guys are trying to move on with their lives, and with the band, but they want to do whats right for them, the band, the fans, but especially their music. We could have lost Avenged completely, Mike helped them heal, perhaps the next person on the kit will help them heal further. Maybe they’ll get to the point where they can bring someone else in permanently, maybe not, but I respect them for being open and honest with all of us.
That was very well said!
Comment by SS December 17, 2010 @ 6:31 pmI was thinking exactly the same thing but didn’t know how to say it- I think you’ve hit the nail on the head but have done so far more eloquently :)
Thanks! I’m told I’m good with words, I’m glad this time I was. :o)
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 6:54 pmFair enough, I could have misunderstood it – actually sorry to see I’m not the only one if it’s the case. Yes, I got into A7X music because of MP, I obtained all previous albums, I really like most of their work and I felt in love with you guys, A7X fan base that feels like huge family. And you embraced Mike so dearly, were so supportive, so sad and upset after his yesterdays statement about rumors. But am I misinterpreting again? A7X cares so much about their extended family fans, their opinion and asks to give love and support whoever they choose (possibly again and again). What I was seeing the day before in numerous comments was confusion and saddens over MP’s departure, so many tnx and love for the man. Today is the new day, please forget how you felt yesterday and let’s do the same thing with another drummer, says Mr. Shadows. Now everyone says ‘’they’re the band and can do whatever they want (which is true indeed), we’ll support’’. Sorry, this doesn’t work with me right. If you don’t feel a bit fooled around, don’t mind being sad over nothing (it’s just a rock band – no big deal and nothing to do with our personal life and strong emotions, so the family thing is ruined again) OK, enjoy it.
Comment by EnchantedW December 18, 2010 @ 1:26 amBottom line: the only proper thing to do if there’s nothing between the lines, everything is clear and agreed from the beginning of the collaboration is to make ONE statement about the change coming from both sides, shaking hands, credits and then everyone moves on his way in love and peace. Everything else sucks.
I do understand what you’re saying, but I don’t believe the guys are asking us to forget how we felt at Mikes statement. We welcomed Mike and were happy to have him for how he helped the guys and us, we still are thankful and supper him, however after the bands statement we understand that this wad the plan all along and now we will continue to support them in what comes next. There are some sour grapes out there about Mike leaving, but no one ever made Mike an official member of the band. It sounds like the band didn’t feel like he was the right long term fit and they are looking to see if they can find someone who might be. Other bands have gone thru various drummers to find the right fit and I don’t think it it will hurt the guys or fans to do the same to found the right person. We aren’t writing Mike off, and I hope he is leaving them on good terms. As to why they didn’t make a joint statement, it seems Mike might be the person to ask. Did he decide to make a statement on his own against the bands plan? Did they tell him to make his own? Did they agree to make separate statements? Or did the guys plan to handle it differently? We don’t know and probably never will. I think the majority of us are sad to see him go but understand to some degree why, and we wish him well and good luck in what comes next for him, but we also stand beside AVENGED and support what they chose to continue forward.
Comment by Elin December 18, 2010 @ 8:38 amI never really got to see Avenged with Jimmy, but saw them twice with Mike and was blown away. It will br weird
Silly touch screen…..
Comment by Elin December 18, 2010 @ 8:42 amit will be weird seeing someone new behind the kit again, but we do have to trust the guys know what’s best for their band and music and that they didn’t feel that was Mike. Its possible Mike didn’t feel he was right for it either as in some ways he would always be constrained by Jimmy’s legacy and style and not free to let go with what he wanted to do with the music.
that’s all just my view though.
I’ve been with you guys for almost six years and anything you guys decide I’m with you. Though it’s sad to see Portnoy go I respect your decisions. Even if no one will be able to fill in the Rev’s seat, having a new drummer help carry on his, and the bands, music is touching, emotional, and very, very exciting. To me, Mike Portnoy will always be a major part of the A7X Family. He helped us off our feet in 2010 and helped make Nightmare the success that it is. And for that, Mike, I say thank you very much. And for the band I’m excited to see what you’ve got for us in 2011.
Comment by Rocky December 17, 2010 @ 3:46 pmA7X foREVer.
I’ll support them no matter what they do, and this seems like I good thing for them to do right now. Mike was awesome though, I’m gonna miss him. Now I’m just curious who this new drummer is
Comment by E December 17, 2010 @ 3:55 pmWish it could be Mike, but they’re right. I will always consider him part of the family. I can’t wait to see the new guy. foREVer.
Comment by mike December 17, 2010 @ 4:36 pmVery beautifully written. I am so happy that they are not jumping into adding a permanent member. So ‘typcial’ Avenged Sevenfold, doing things THEIR way on THEIR terms.
What also gave me the warm fuzzies was this line.. ‘In other words, in this family, we take these steps together, band and our extended fan family.’ It makes me almost giddy knowing that they still care what their fans think.
Boys, you KNOW we are standing beside you 110% on any decisions you make. I am excited for the changes ahead & yet, a little nervous BUT I know whatever lays ahead, it will be GREAT!!
We love you!
Comment by Andrea December 17, 2010 @ 4:52 pmfoREVer
Oh dear, uncertainty central yet again. I saw Avenged twice on the UK tour and I’ll be honest, Portnoy fit. I understand what Matt’s saying about it not being about the individual, but doesn’t he realise that it will ALWAYS be about that, because if they have talent and experience from other bands that will always be commented on, but if they’re new blood the comparisons to Jimmy, to Mike, to whoever will begin.. And I’m not talkin about A7X fans, this is the critics and album/show reviewers. Slipknot are going to have the exact same problem, I’m not going to see them in the summer because that isn’t my 9 anymore.. But I support Avenged all the way, I just wish perhaps they should focus on the music and care less about the tweets..
Comment by Jojo December 17, 2010 @ 5:12 pmavenged sevenfold & mike portnoy were just that because he was never a member of the band. it’ll it avenged sevenfold & this new dude until/if they welcome him into the band as their permanent drummer. in any case if they ever find a permanent, then it should be looked at as avenged sevenfold because whether people like it or not he will be their drummer. the band already has a constant reminder jimmys not there, they dont need to read about it too with comparisons and i hope dbn doesn’t allow it from people who just arent happy about it. no one will ever be jimmy but people need to face it he’s not here anymore.
did u not READ what was bolded in the entry below? his tweets had nothing to do with it, nor did the privacy thing. that entire situation had to do with mike leaving dream theater and nothing to do with why he was let go from avenged.
Comment by hunter December 17, 2010 @ 5:41 pmI support them no matter what, I love them so much! <3 Does this mean we're gonna have to wait til the first tour date to find out who is gonna be drumming for them
Comment by francyA7X December 17, 2010 @ 5:30 pmI’ll support no matter what… They have a valid point and I respect them for that (: a7x foREVer (:
Comment by EmilyA7X December 17, 2010 @ 6:05 pmStill my favorite band… and as a straight up musician, the Rev was as good as it gets, IMO… but short of Neil Peart and Keith Moon, there has never been a drummer as good as Portnoy… I will still attend every A7X show that comes my way, and they will be awesome shows… but… unless they somehow swoop in and take peart from Rush, they will never have that ultra high level drumming again…
Comment by Brian December 17, 2010 @ 6:26 pmIsn’t it possible that there is someone with that high level who isn’t in a famous band already that they may stumble upon and the chemistry and everything will just click? I don’t think you can really say they’ll never have it until we find out who they’re bringing in and how good they are. Just a thought, anything is still possible.
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 6:52 pmSure it is possible that they can find an up and comer that has the ability of Portnoy, but what are the chances? in the history of music, I look at the top tier drummers and I see 3 that belong in that tier (Portnoy, Moon and Peart)… so it is not very likely that they find a youngster as good as Portnoy.
Comment by Brian December 18, 2010 @ 11:05 amPerhaps. But it is still possible that they’ve stumbled on someone we know nothing about. I really know nothing about drumming and who is top and who isn’t, but if the guys think whoever he is is the right fit for now, I’m willing to give them a chance and see what they can do.
Comment by Elin December 18, 2010 @ 3:53 pmThese guys have expressed the situation in the most humble and beautiful way, i see there are still some fans who are confused and angry, but i seriously dont understand how you can get angry at these great people.
Comment by AW December 17, 2010 @ 6:42 pmNo disrespect to Portnoy at all but there are plenty of drummers who are perfectly capable of competing with him. They’re perhaps not so mainstream but they’re definitely there.
Comment by Anonymous December 17, 2010 @ 6:53 pmPortnoy mainstream????? Have you heard Dream Theater. They are one of the least mainstream bands I’ve heard.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 7:20 pmunderstand the meaning of mainstream. It’s not how they sound, it’s how well they’re known, and DT is well known. Calling them mainstream is actually a complement, as its much harder to get recognition in their genre.
Comment by happyfatman December 17, 2010 @ 7:36 pmActually mainstream means how well it appeals to the GENERAL PUBLIC. DT does not appeal to the general public.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 7:46 pmYes, thank you, I have heard Dream Theater :)
Comment by Anonymous December 17, 2010 @ 7:53 pmI didn’t mean mainstream as in, say, Rihanna-type mainstream or run-of-the-mill type mainstream. No-one can accuse them of being either of those two things…
I used the term to represent the fact that they are one of the bigger names in their genre. happyfatman (thanks, by the way!) below me summarised it quite well…
Poor Avenged… They still can’t get over the fact that their friend is dead and he’s not coming back. I know they are grieving, but that’s no reason to bag the best drummer in the world because he’s too good!?!?!?
Listen to the new Metal Hammer Podcast. They pretty much some up Avenged perfectly. “The rich kid only child who gets everything he wants all the time.” In a week I’ve gone from adoring this band to continually questioning their motives. They complain about Mikes personal affairs with his own band, the complain about having to play during the day at Soundwave, they bag portnoy because he’s not their dead friend. I am fed up with their bullshit “poor us.” Get over it, drop your continually growing but still massive egos, and move on with your lives. And if DBN censors or deletes my comment, it will continue the largest fall from grace I’ve ever seen from a band.
Try and argue all you want. But you can’t deny what gill said, “no one will join this band because they aren’t big enough twats.”
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 7:13 pmyou are one ignorant individual. if you cant understand their loss and what it means to them not only as people but as a bad then i feel sorry for you. this is their band, they can do what they want – regardless of if you like it or not. go on an give up on them, i highly doubt they would miss having someone like you as a fan.
Comment by jon December 17, 2010 @ 7:22 pmI can’t understand their loss? I was an Army Ranger for 9 years and I lost 2 friends while on the battlefield. I was devastated for about a month, as you have no idea what it’s like to go to a young mans parents and tell them how you couldn’t save their son. I lived with those guys for a year and I can’t understand loss??? That’s a joke if I’ve ever heard one…
And if they care as much about their fans as they say they do, than they would care if they lost me. And let me tell you they’re very close to losing me. Their blind and ignorant fans don’t help their case either.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 7:29 pmwell then it sounds like you can, which just makes you even more of an ignorant person for making the comments that you did. they dont need people like you telling them to “get over it” – you can go be heartless elsewhere. no one is blind and ignorant, we understand that this is their band and they can do what they see fit. people need to get off of mike’s nuts. he was never a member of the band, him leaving at the end of 2010 WAS ALWAYS THE PLAN.
Comment by jon December 17, 2010 @ 7:36 pmShadows needs to get off mikes nuts too. Leave the DT situation out of this. It’s none of A7Xs business. Mike was being a great guy saying that it had nothing to do with them.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 7:39 pmexcept he wasnt on mike’s nuts. he should have either left DT before he started out on the road with avenged or waited until after. he knew that leaving the band while out on tour with avenged would bring them bad press.
Comment by jon December 17, 2010 @ 7:45 pmMatt didn’t bring the DT situation into this. The other post was probably an interview that happened shortly after Mike left DT. I might be wrong on the timing tho.
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 7:46 pmYou compare living with 2 guys 1 year to living, knowing and being in a band with someone you’ve known for your whole life? That’s what you’re doing?
Comment by Loghen December 17, 2010 @ 7:43 pmI’m sorry for your loss, but it’s nothing like losing your best friend who was also a huge part of the band we’re talking about.
Stop acting like you know what’s best for them. They’ve carried this band for 10 years and they know what they are doing, and if you don’t like the fact that they let the Almighty Mike Portnoy go, too bad because it already happened, and your childish attitude with stupid sarcasm won’t make you better than them.
How the hell do you compare your loss to theirs?
Now if you’re that upset about A7X not kissing MP’s ass, do us a favor and get the hell out of here cause you’re not gonna change a thing. You think you know what they are/went going through because 2 persons that you lived a year with died?
That’s a joke if I’ve ever heard one…
And sorry if I’m being too rude, or acting like your loss meant nothing at all, I just can’t stand ignorant comments like ”Get over it” as if someone who says that know exactly how they feel about this situation.
Comment by Loghen December 17, 2010 @ 7:47 pmAlright. It’s cool. I’m very sorry I served my country and my friends died… All I was saying is that I do know what loss feels like. I know what they are going through. But I don’t bring it up in every single thing I do in my life.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 8:00 pmMaybe not and I’m sorry you’ve had to deal with that, (I really am- no-one deserves that…) but people deal with grief differently. Some like to talk about the departed a lot, others don’t. It depends on the bereaved individual more than anything… How long you’ve known someone, the relationship you had with them… These things aren’t always factors that determine how long or in what manner we grieve.
Comment by Anonymous December 17, 2010 @ 8:10 pmAnd in A7X’s case, I suspect they may also do it to help the fans grieve too. Many of us only have this community with which to express how we feel about Jimmy’s passing and I’m pretty sure they’re aware of this…
No one is saying you’re wrong for serving your country or for losing your friend. No one is speaking down to your loss. But you seem to have a disregard for the loss of the guys. This is their way to grieve. You grieved your way, it took you a month, I wish it took such a short time for me. While it may not affect every aspect of my life, there are things that always strike me. Let the guys grieve the way works for them and respect that. Judging someones way they grieve is quite mean because we are all different, you can’t tell someone how or when to grieve.
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 8:12 pmGet over it? Just a question, has anyone that you love (parent, grandparent, sibling, aunt or uncle, cousin, etc.) that you were extremely close to died? Your initial statement tells me you don’t understand losing someone like they have at all, and probably never had to grieve for anyone like this. Grieving doesn’t end in a year, it doesn’t end because others who don’t understand think it should. Grieving can take years, or an entire lifetime to get through. You cannot put a scale to when grieving for such a big loss should end.
It doesn’t say they bagged Mike cuz he’s too good. They anticipated that he’d be with them only until 2011, that is what happened. And regardless of what someone in a podcast says, I think they will have a variety of drummers willing to take up the kit, be it temporary or eventually in a permanent capacity.
You’re entitled to your opinions and all, but so are all the rest of us. And we support the band and what they are doing, even if we don’t totally understand it. The world will forget about the band’s pain, life will move on for everyone, but it doesn’t change that the band and their families are still living with the pain every day. Have some compassion and understand for that even if you don’t approve of the roads and decisions the band are taking professionally.
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 7:34 pmYes I have lost people close to me. Read my reply to Jon…
Also, everybody acts as if Jimmy was the messiah of drumming when he was not. He was good. Not great. Not the greatest ever. Just good. People need to realize that.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 7:43 pmAlright then. Lets see you do better.
Comment by Alyssa December 17, 2010 @ 7:52 pmI never said I could do better. I was just saying that he not the greatest like everyone says he is.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 8:02 pmBut he was a hell of a lot better then “good.” Sure, he wasn’t the worlds best drummer, but he wasn’t average either.
Comment by Alyssa December 17, 2010 @ 8:12 pmI saw your reply after I posted this. Okay, so you’ve lost people, but their response back to you is valid. Jimmy grew up with them, was their best friend and brother and band mate. While I can’t begin to understand what you went through with your loss, I don’t really think the two are comparable. But okay, you were devastated for a month when you lost people you knew for a year, they grew up together, knew each other longer, lived, breathed, partied, etc together. I think it’ll take longer for them to heal and move on. Speaking for myself, there are times I find I’m still not over those I’ve lost in my life, and most of them were 10 or more years ago. It will always hurt to some degree.
I also disagree with your second…point. We aren’t viewing him as the messiah of drumming, but as fans we are convinced he was the best one to be on the kit in Avenged. Personally, I know little to nothing about drums, but I look at what I saw Jimmy do and I’m amazed, I also feel the same about Mike and others as well. But I do think you’re misreading how everyone views him. But he is the drummer for Avenged, if not him, no one else quite lives up, because Avenged is Matt, Brian, Zacky, Johnny and Jimmy, it has been for 10+ years, and now we’re trying to figure out what comes next without Jimmy, thats all.
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 7:56 pmso does that make his life expendable then?
Comment by Mark December 17, 2010 @ 8:04 pmNo. Nobodys life is expendable. Though he shouldn’t have done drugs or drank that much.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 8:27 pmEvery drummer is “great” in their own rights, and although Jimmy might not have been widely recognized, he was the BEST drummer for Avenged. So, in all of our eyes, true fans of Avenged, he was the best fucking drummer ever! If you can’t say something positive about the band, go over to Mike’s website, where they argue, bitch, and moan. Take it elsewhere!
Comment by strunk22 December 18, 2010 @ 2:03 pmum, where’s the “Like” button?!?!?!
Comment by LittleMissRESENTMENT December 17, 2010 @ 8:02 pmLOL thanks? :o)
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 8:09 pmNow how in the fuckin hell do they bag Portnoy for him not being their “dead friend?”
Comment by Alyssa December 17, 2010 @ 7:47 pmThey can do whatever the fuck they want, whether you like any of their “motives” or not. And, if you lose respect for them completely, who is going to give a shit? One fan lost equals another fan gained, right? Gill and Beez are assholes to begin with, so who really cares about what they have to say? (and the both of them must be in pretty pissy moods, becuase as far as I know, Metal Hammer has always respected Avenged) The reason why they were getting into Mikes “personal affairs with his own band” was becuase they were being slung into the middle of it by fans of both bands. Do you really think that is their fault? And I know I will get flamed for this, and as much as I respect Mike, he has been acting like a “drama queen” with the whole DT situation. I DO agree with Matt that he might have gotten a little too “press happy.”
Anyways, think what you want of A7X, now, later, or never, but I think the majority of people will at least be able to respect their decision and accept their choices.
Aah. Ignorance is bliss isn’t it. Everybody loved Gill and Beez when they said positive things about Avenged.
Also, Portnoy didn’t get press happy. The press got Portnoy happy. And mikes a drama queen? What about Avenged who canceled their show because they couldn’t compete with Maiden. And they couldn’t get the slot they wanted even though they aren’t nearly as massive as Maiden.
“They can do whatever the fuck they want” (see I can drop quotes too!). That is what I have a problem with. They think they can do what they want even though they aren’t Metallica, Iron Maiden, or Tool like they think they are. Once they become as massive as those three bands and can headline festivals, then they can do whatever they want. Until then, they’re still the snotty rich only child who only gets what they want and pouts when they don’t.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 8:12 pmnot even worth my time. you cant even come up with your own argument – you just paraphrased the entire gill & beez podcast.
Comment by jon December 17, 2010 @ 8:23 pm“Ignorance is bliss?” Lmfao, good one. Unless you are really convinced with that jackass soundwave organizer AJ’s argument, Avenged didn’t want their time slot moved because they thought that they were better than Iron Maiden, they wanted their time slot moved because of their stage production (pyro, fireworks, etc.). Even Larry confirmed that it had nothing to do with Maiden (unless you choose to be narrow-minded and think that he is lying).
Comment by Alyssa December 17, 2010 @ 8:28 pmOK, really?? If you are *that* angry, than ‘unfan’ yourself. Yes, you are totally entitled to share your opinions but it sounds like you just need to step away. Not everyone thinks like you dude, sorry.
We may be family & thanks to DBN Lady, we know pretty much when the guys take a shit, but I sure as hell know we do not know EVERYthing. There may be more to this whole story than we may never know. But you know what? I personally don’t care. It’s their life & their band.. & as long as they keep playing, I will be beside them 110%
And for the record, I truly am sorry you lost 2 friends. I’ve been an Army wife for 10 yrs, I’ve lost many friends as well. Lossing someone is not easy. You honestly can’t expect the boys to ‘get over’ loosing Jimmy this quick. We all grieve differently & this is how they do it.
Maybe it’s YOU who needs to get over it..
Comment by Andrea December 17, 2010 @ 7:55 pmtanner we had a much more cordial exchange a few days ago on another thread, and im in much less of a mood to be nice to you this time. your first sentence was one of the most heartless, spiteful things i have ever heard someone say, maybe you have a different way of dealing with grief than they do but thats no reason for you to judge them. thats great that you can listen to a podcast full of elitist metalheads who never have accepted avenged for the simple reason that they do not try to be the loudest, heaviest, fastest band of all time but instead focus on making their music connect with people. people like that are closed-minded, they have never and will never accept avenged and will jump on any opportunity to give them shit.
your soundwave comment is about as ignorant as you got on your entire post. the man who made those allegations about a7x, aj maddah, has a history of publicly humiliating various bands to get a leg up on negotiations with them. you are talking as if avenged made a public stink about soundwave when in fact they put out the most neutral, non-accusatory message one could possibly come up with.
they did not kick out portnoy, he was never a permanent member of the band no matter what all the fanboys may have thought. they moved in a different direction so that they could build their own legacy instead of feed off his, if you have a problem with that than you need to wake up to the real world, you dont think there has ever been a time when an employer has had to lay off an employee because their company was losing money? they did it as respectfully as they could, the guy is a hero of theirs of course their not going to treat him bad.
if you want to join in with all the unemployed, greasy-haired, bandwagon avenged sevenfold haters who live in their parents basements, you can do that, but you strike me as a much smarter person than that, so next time think before you rip an authentic, hard-working band like avenged
Comment by Mark December 17, 2010 @ 7:56 pmGood post!
We seem to have a lot of very eloquent writers on board tonight ^^
Comment by SS December 17, 2010 @ 8:14 pmhaha i try, thanks for the props =D
Comment by Mark December 18, 2010 @ 6:46 pmFYI gill and Beez picked Deftones as their band of the year. In no way are Deftones the fastest, the heaviest, or the band for elitist metal heads.
I live in my moms basement? Yeah I do. I went to West Point and served as an officer in the military and I live in my moms basement. Yup… How’d you know?
Also, it’s quite obvious they bagged portnoy.
Plus, they did withdraw from their performances. It’s easy to draw a conclusion that they cancelled because they couldn’t get the slot they wanted. Like I just said, until they suddenly morph into Metallica, Maiden, Tool, or Judas Priest and can headline festivals then they can do what they want. They also cancelled many UK tours for no apparent reason. Now, I’m not British, but that’s fishy.
Comment by Tanner December 17, 2010 @ 8:25 pmAlright folks – this is ending here. No one’s agreeing with anyone else and I’m not about to let one argument turn into another. You’ve all got your different opinions and that’s fine, they’ve been said and now it’s done.
Comment by deathbatnews December 17, 2010 @ 8:30 pmSorry for getting all heated/defensive/argumentative. We are a passionate bunch, aren’t we? lol
Comment by Elin December 17, 2010 @ 8:38 pmWell, I guess I am sorry as well. My arguementive side was showing more than it should have been..
Comment by Alyssa December 17, 2010 @ 8:56 pmI have a somewhat mixed opinion about this. Avenged is by far my favorite band and I’m glad to be part of the family. But I think a lot of the people forget what A7X are. They’re a band. They’re certainly not perfect and they have made a lot of mistakes. No matter what they do or say though, everyone on here agrees completely and praises their infallible decisions. Every time they come out with a song or even a preview, everyone says they love it, just because its A7X. I think a lot of the people on here really are blinded by obsession. I am not however agreeing with the rest of the points tanner made above. The band are not letting jimmys loss affect everything they do. The only thing we hear about them is their music, which is obviously going to be affected by jimmy because he was in the band.
Comment by abe December 18, 2010 @ 7:58 pmYou have absolutely every type of fan visiting Deathbat News. The ones you just explained, they ones who are open-minded, the ones who truly do live everything they do, the young ones, the old ones – but in the end I run this website the way I see fit and that’s at a mature and professional level. I do not want to wake up to see tons of comments with people bickering back and forth and have to babysit. If you guys want to have arguments that’s fine, but be mature about it.
As far as this string of comments in concerned – Nothing new was being said. One person had his opinion, everyone else had their own and they were doing nothing but going round-and-round with them. There’s no reason for people to continue to comment when nothing is going to change and they’re just going to say the same thing someone else has already said.
Comment by deathbatnews December 19, 2010 @ 7:59 ami gotta be honest…i love u guys but gettin rid of portnoy was absolutely retarded…hes awesome n so r u, u should keep it going, the family of A7X, n portnoy is in it
Comment by Mr. Grim December 17, 2010 @ 7:56 pmWhoever is their new drummer I respect their decision. A7x knows better than us. Thanks MP! For helping them with nightmare!
Comment by #LOVEAvengedSevenfold December 17, 2010 @ 8:14 pmWow, you all need to chill with the drama. Quit comparing who knows whats best and who knows what its like to lose someone close to them. We all need to just chill, let them make their own choices and just enjoy their music, both new and old, no matter who the new guy(s) happen to be. For those of you who wish it was mike, sorry but that has come to an end, but that’s not to say that they won’t hook up again sometime in the future(maybe even for a song or something). I mean I am sure they are still friends, they seemed to be friends in Vegas from what I saw.
So again, lets all be mature and chill out.
Comment by Nick C December 17, 2010 @ 8:22 pmif any of you kids knew portnoy or dream theaters past. then you wouldnt want him as a permanant member. yeah, hes a great drummer and a pretty good dude. at the same time, hes very outspoken, and mainly the ego of his band. he always has a say in everything he does. trust me, this is not his band to have a say in.
Comment by austins December 17, 2010 @ 8:45 pmmy sentiments exactly…not to mention A7X really needs a drummer who can sing back up vocals…something MP should never do.
Comment by snuffy December 17, 2010 @ 10:22 pmBetween Soundwave and Mike, all of this has turned into one big muddy mess…
Comment by Alyssa December 17, 2010 @ 9:13 pmIt’s only as big as we, the fans, make it.
Comment by Nick C December 17, 2010 @ 9:34 pmso have they found a new drummer but they just haven’t announced it yet or are they still deciding between a couple different guys?
Comment by drew December 17, 2010 @ 9:27 pmA7X will always have my full fledged support. In my opinion, their music is really the only music worth listening to. However, thats not what I came here to talk about. With the Vegas show having been the second show I’ve seen A7X play without Jimmy, I finally felt as though Sevenfold was a band again. I agree, when I saw them back on July 31st, it felt like “A7X plus Mike Portnoy”. After all the terrific reviews, fantastic success, and bonding that had happened since that show, the Vegas show certainly felt like AVENGED SEVENFOLD. As a matter of fact, it was hands down THE BEST A7X SHOW EVER (Vegas being my 6th show)!!! I can’t help but feel that this is a step in the wrong direction. I know it’s THEIR band, and ultimately, THEIR decision…..I’m just extremely disappointed. As I said before, A7X will always have my full support. I have tickets to the show in Lowell, MA and I will be even more disappointed if this show feels like A7X plus “some dude”. At least we knew who Mike was. At least he had a proven track record. He was the one who stepped up and helped us ALL out when he could have said that he wouldn’t. He respected the fans, and he respected Jimmy. Both shows I went to, he got a HUGE applause when introduced. Who is this new guy??? Someone their friends introduced them to who plays drums in his parents basement??? Maybe I’m all alone on this one, but Mike was family. In my eyes, he was THE BEST replacement the guys could find. I wish him the best of luck, and I hope he finds something to move on with soon. Well guys, I’ll see you Jan 22nd. Please don’t let me down.
Comment by Weber December 17, 2010 @ 9:48 pmI agree with your whole post but the only thing I have to say is that I feel VERY sorry for you if Avenged is all you deem worthy to listen to. I can say as a huge lover of MUSIC in general that you are missing out on a hell of alot of amazing stuff out there, if only you’d take the time to find it.
Comment by TonyT December 17, 2010 @ 10:40 pmRespact!
Comment by EnchantedW December 18, 2010 @ 1:46 amThat’s a true fan who doesn’t close his eyes to the obvious, makes no drama, but just doesn’t buy everything.
The ting is, they’ll hardly come up with someone who wouldn’t be just ”some guy behind the kit … how was his name, again?” after Rev and now after Mike. The trouble is now double …
eh it will ALWAYS be ‘A7X plus some dude’
Comment by AJ Lee December 18, 2010 @ 6:21 amNo. He (whoever they choose) will be the drummer for Avenged Sevenfold = Avenged Sevenfold.
Comment by Loghen December 18, 2010 @ 12:38 pmill be at the lowell show as well, im really looking forward to it. as for your “a7x plus some dude” comment, i think its important that we give the guy a chance before we dismiss him. im sure many metallica fans viewed jason newsted as “some dude” at the beginning, but over time he earned their respect. personally im going to give the new guy a chance to prove himself, whether ive heard of him or not.
Comment by Mark December 18, 2010 @ 7:14 am‘the family’ will complain and cry at first and then ‘welcome’ him in to ‘the family’ :P
Comment by AJ Lee December 18, 2010 @ 9:12 amWell here’s, I think, an interesting question to you, Ms. DBN. Will you be reporting any news about Mike even if it isn’t A7x related, and if so, how long will you continue doing it?
Comment by JIK December 17, 2010 @ 10:22 pmIf it’s not A7X related than no.
Comment by deathbatnews December 18, 2010 @ 7:18 amHuge props to MP and I am greatful for what he did for the band and all a7x fans. But I think it became evident to the guys that, in the long run, and despite his god like drumming talets, MP just wasn’t a good fit. I know it may sound harsh…but he was a bit of a drama queen. His tweets just stirred up too much shit. Avenged is very strategic about their press releases…and they always carry an optimistic and exciting message…something to entice the fans. MP aired is laundry in public and even his most of even his most loyal fans have grown weary of it. If you don’t believe me, head over to the MP forums and read some of the releated threads.
Comment by snuffy December 17, 2010 @ 10:47 pmIf you haven’t noticed…Avenged knows what they are doing…These guys really know what works and what doesn’t in every aspect of their music, image and marketing (they are already more popular than DT ever was and MP basically ran that show for 20 years so what does that tell you?). They will be a better band without MP…no disrespect intended…I am a MP fan and will remain one. I just really believe he wasn’t a good fit for the long run.
I thank you for this comment, reading this makes me realise that not all MP fans are out to have a go at A7X. And you make a fair point about DT. I’d never even heard of the band until Mike offered to help the guys out. Then incidentally the other day I went into a local music store [in Perth Australia] and saw some DT albums in there…but I would’ve just walked by them before all this.
Comment by Marlz December 18, 2010 @ 10:43 pmI like a7x better than DT…just more my style. But I highly encourage you to give DT a listen. Wither and the count of Tuscany are two great songs off their last album….but they have a ton of good songs (i just wish they would abandon the keyboard in favor of the piano!)
Comment by snuffy December 19, 2010 @ 8:29 amThanks for the reccs, I will definitely check them out. And, haha, yeah… piano is much more dynamic than keyboard.
Comment by Marlz December 20, 2010 @ 3:03 amDont pay this douche any attention. hes just trying to stir up some bullshit & get everyone at eachothers throats. Id pay good money to watch m shadows lay him out….
Comment by dani December 17, 2010 @ 11:05 pmI’m done with this… These people just won’t get it.
Comment by Loghen December 18, 2010 @ 12:18 amI will support you guys in whatever may come,
I trust you in your’ choise because when it comes to choose a great musision, who can it do better then 4 other great musisions.
thank you for all your’ great music guys
love from Holland
Comment by Daan6661 December 18, 2010 @ 1:24 amThis made me teared up…
They said in the begining that Mike is not staying with them permanently, the truth is that I’ve been hoping he will… But hey, I’ll support them no matter what. It’s their decision and I believe it to be a good decision.
Comment by Aneta December 18, 2010 @ 2:50 amA7X foREVer
why do some people on here think they booted mike?
Comment by me December 18, 2010 @ 3:14 amits been said time and time again that he was with A7X only till the end of the year O.o
they need a reason to cry lmao :D
Comment by AJ Lee December 18, 2010 @ 9:11 amI support you guys 10000%. Through think and thin. Family foREVer. Thanks for everything Mike.
xxxxX
Comment by Shell December 18, 2010 @ 3:28 amHonestly after reading this I feel alot better about the MP thing. I was reading it to my little 11 year old sister and she made a great point.
Mike was never going to be our Jimmy. He helped our guys get to the point where they knew they could carry on. No one will ever replace our Jimmy or their best friend their brother. If they have enough faith in someone new to give them a try then we all will to. They aren’t gonna let us down so we aren’t going to let them down.
Something about this post was very emotional, I guess it’s because of the fact that it’s so close to the place we were all in last year. The pain of still not having Jimmy and still letting go and top that off with not knowing what’s going to happen next. All I can say is that no matter what I stand behind whatever decisions the guys make.
foREVer <3
Comment by Stephy December 18, 2010 @ 5:35 amI have to say they are taking the correct and very smart approach. If MP did infact join A7X, they would get attention just due to MP and not on a band level. It will be interesting to see who they take out. I also like the lack of name dropping, keeping us in the dark a bit.
As for touring (I know I sound like a broken record) don’t forget Connecticut again. Here’s to another great year for A7X. Also, Portnoy we love you and thank you.
Comment by Ed December 18, 2010 @ 5:48 amLowell, MA kid!!!!
Comment by Weber December 18, 2010 @ 9:20 pmYeah well that is about over 2 hour drive for me(one way) a bit too far for one show. If I am going to spend more time driving than at the show then its too far.
Comment by Ed December 21, 2010 @ 7:59 amI love that these guys have always presented themselves as a family first and a band second. They are a united front and they have never let anything or anyone come between them. Since they started out so young the music business could have chewed them up and spit them out but their heads and hearts have remained in the right place and they have surrounded themselves with the right people. A7X is their brand and their business and they have protected that by having input on everything that they do and not letting anything become bigger than their brotherhood. Not that anyone gives a shit what I think, but ultimately deciding to move on without MP was the right decision and I just hope the fans and the critics accept that and embrace his tour replacement with open arms. MP will be fine and, if anything, he will have an even higher profile now after playing on ‘Nightmare’ and touring with Avenged. I look forward to hearing what he does in the future.
Comment by D December 18, 2010 @ 5:50 amI may be late in the posting. I’ve read all of the comments and have to say some of them made me really sad. A few pissed me off! I have to admit I was a bit surprised when A7X said Portnoy was done. I was actually surprised with myself for being sad. I am really thankful for Mike, but I never really felt he was part of A7X. He’s kind of a whiner and before you all get offended, let me explain why.
Zacky is the main guy on the internet for A7X. He’s the mind of the internet stuff. He’s always upbeat and his posting are never personal. He doesn’t complain or get mad. Mike’s Twitter and FB where always about how tired he was or how bad touring is. He was always whining about something. I always felt like he had a bit of an ego. Yes, an ego. That doesn’t fit the A7X bill. I always felt that he feels we should thank him that he helped us. In the you owe me way.
Another thing is, even if you don’t admit it, we all have said Avenged Sevenfold and Mike. He never would have been truely a part of A7X. His heart and legacy is DT. If he is used to running DT do you honestly think he isn’t going to try to run A7X or be comfortable just playing drums? Plus he was playing Jimmy’s style. Mike DOES NOT play drums like that normally. He was copying Jimmy..
As fans we should just be happy they are moving on. We can get back to our new normal and move on as a “family”. We may not agree with them, but it wasn’t too long ago everyone was saying they wanted A7X to continue on NO MATTER WHAT. We got what we wanted. Let’s get over it. I will be there in January at their show screaming extra loud to show the new drummer that we are behind the guys moving on….That is what the guys asked for after all….
Comment by Nikki V December 18, 2010 @ 7:18 amTHANK YOU.
Comment by Loghen December 18, 2010 @ 12:46 pmyeah i completely agree with you..
Comment by jj December 18, 2010 @ 2:47 pmTheres a very ego driven vibe between the lines with him. Dont get me wrong hes very talented and a nice guy and without him i wouldnt have got to see them twice this year but, i tried to google the sitation today and saw an article about how mike said he got booted from avenged on a jersery shore website. dont even ask me how it ended up there and im sure its just the media twisting things. But there is no way in hell any article about them especially a negative one would end up on a website like that until he was in the group.
Well said. Well said. I agree entirely.
Comment by Marlz December 18, 2010 @ 10:40 pmI first was shocked that A7x part ways with MP but after this statement I fully understand them. I will still support the guys no matter what. I hope they are going to move on with the band and that they don’t quit, it hurts to know that it will never be the same after the passing of The Rev but it still is the other 4 people I love.
Comment by DanTheA7xFan December 18, 2010 @ 7:41 amI feel the same :)
Comment by RaZoR December 18, 2010 @ 3:42 pmI’m glad they don’t want a new permanent member!
Comment by Will0240 A7X forREVer December 18, 2010 @ 7:57 amI don’t want them to live the rest of their career with a new drummer every year or two, though.
Comment by Mike December 18, 2010 @ 8:23 amhow did this post turn into taking sides? or how did it turn into who’s a “better drummer” & how a7x are “stupid” for “moving on”? the initial plan was that mike was TEMPORARY. end of story. it was said in the beginning, & it’s been said now. he was only there to record & share jimmys legacy for the first year. no one should be upset, shocked or pissed. but thankful, hopeful & excited for whats to come & who else is going to HELP the band continue. it’s just mike guys… (yes to be thankful for what he’s done) but it’s not the 4 men OF avenged sevenfold so chill the EFF out. i’m really surprised at how you guys are taking this.
Comment by Anonymous December 18, 2010 @ 8:11 amI agree with your post. We should be glad the guys are moving on. The whole Mike thing got way out of hand. A7X always said he was a temporary drummer that was all and now that his time has come to an end a lot are making a big deal about it. Mike brought this on himself. He left his band and then says he’s sad DT is continuing without him, that’s kinds messed up to say. A lot of his tweets and comments have suggested he that he wanted to continue touring with A7X but the guys never promised him anything.
I just think we should all just give A7X our support, they are doing what they feel is best for the band that’s all.
Comment by dream December 18, 2010 @ 10:15 amTheir statements make people really feel like part of a family. A huge thank you to MP && all the work he did to allow Jimmy’s legacy to live on.
Comment by Ericka December 18, 2010 @ 9:40 amThanks dbn for always deleting my comments don crap about the spam thing
Comment by #LOVEAvengedSevenfold December 18, 2010 @ 10:35 amIt was one comment and it was about who should be their next drummer. I’ve already stated comments like that were going to be deleted.
Comment by deathbatnews December 18, 2010 @ 3:46 pmITs who should I said it would PROBABLY BE NOT DEFINITELY GOSH!
Comment by #LOVEAvengedSevenfold December 18, 2010 @ 8:12 pmRegardless – you made a comment about who “it would probably be” and I already stated before the comment was made that any talk of who the drummer “should be” or “would be” would be deleted.
Comment by deathbatnews December 19, 2010 @ 7:53 amI saw you guys 2 times this year..once in irvine at the uproar festival and once in vegas for zacky’s birthday, mike performed in both of those shows, and i could just see by the atmosphere and how the fans were reacting that they truly love and respected Mike for his great drumming skills and the fact that he was soo humble. I know that in these 2 concerts and probably all of the other ones ya’ll played with him, he got a great ovation and was truly accepted by the fans.
I just cannot believe that the reason and excuse you guys gave for his departure was that he was somewhat better than you guys and it would be more like A7X with Mike instead of just A7X. I mean seriously, how do you think that makes Mike feel? He toured with you for a whole year, and just like you said in Vegas, this guy hasn’t been home in over a year. He did that all for you guys, he was truly there to help out and be there in this time of need.
I honestly just do not see another drummer being as good a mike was in an all-around way. Now i know i do not know what goes on behind the scenes, yea Mike could possibly be the most difficult person to deal with and has the worst attitude about everything, but i doubt it. The fact that Mike was The Rev’s favorite drummer and the mutual respect that they showed for each other, it just does not make sense that you guys would decide to let him go.
Im saddened by the decision, i really am, ive been listening to you guys since Sounding of the Seven Trumpets so im not just gonna not support ya’ll, i just do not understand why, especially because of the reason why he will no longer be apart of the band in 2011.
Both times i saw you guys play so far away i broke down, i couldn’t help myself, i was overcame with emotion. I just think that the Rev was happy to see that Mike was playing with the band because of the fact that they were friends, i just dont see him being happy with anyone else other than Mike. I know you guys probably wont even read this but from the bottom of my heart, i love you guys, but i just think that this decision is not a good one for the band. Just basically saying thanks Mike for 2010, but we dont need you anymore. I know the decision at the start of the year was having Mike for one year, but as you guys have said many times, its all about the fans, and i just do not see the fans accepting and showing more love to anyone else other than The Rev and Mike.
I love you guys, you music, your amazing live shows, your values and everything you guys stand for, everyone makes mistakes, i just think that this one was unnecessary. No one on this earth will replace The Rev, but who better to continue on his legacy than the drummer that he loved? Just doesn’t make sense to me.
Comment by Joshua F December 18, 2010 @ 10:59 amSweet, but they said a houndred times, including Mike, THIS WAS GOING TO BE TEMPORARY.
Comment by Loghen December 18, 2010 @ 4:02 pmHow Mike feels? He knew this wasn’t going to last forever, the band knew it and WE ALL knew it.
They said that many times.
They’re not even in their 30s yet and of course they won’t want to be labeled as the band that features the legendary Mike Portnoy, who alreadt made a name for himself, in drums for the rest of their career.
It’s not a wrong decision. It has to be a drummer THAT FITS WITH THEIR SOUND, not only a good one.
Those shows that you attended, Mike was playing like Jimmy. Do you think he would be playing like him his whole life had he stayed with A7X?
He is in a different level. Jimmy admired him for his work on DT, which is how Mike usually plays, he didn’t admire him for how good he could imitate other drummers.
So please, get over it. This has been said from the beginning: Mike would tour with them until they found a drummer of their own, which they already did.
everyone is entitled to their own opinions Loghen..i dont care if you think it was a good decision, i just dont, why do you think Mike would want to take over the band when he is already famous and paid his dues? And its not like A7X isn’t famous right? They are known throughout the whole world. All I thought of this was stars combining to make a super fucking dope group. And seriously man who cares if he is older than everyone else? Age is just a number, just look at INXS, lead singers in his 20′s and everyone else is like 40. Shadows syn zacky johnny and the memory of the Rev plus Mike who IN MY OPINION would have been the best replacement for Jimmy
Chill out Loghen it obviously went the way you wanted it anyways, so dont go getting off trying to put people down for their own opinions. Im just saying that because it looks like you spend a lot of time on this website bashing on people’s opinions, which just makes me wonder if you have a life or not. This whole situation is fucked up, everyone is on edge, especially the true fans who have been with them since day 1, just like you and I.
I totally understand and know that the agreement was for MP to tour and help out for 2010, but all I am saying is that from the 2 concerts i went to this year he got standing ovations and was truly accepted by the fans.
Comment by Joshua F December 19, 2010 @ 7:35 pm”it obviously went the way you wanted it anyways”
Comment by Loghen December 19, 2010 @ 8:08 pmLOL, sorry to disappoint you, but no. It went the way Mike and the band said from the beginning. Tour then leave.
I don’t have to give any explanation to you about what I do with my life, but anyway if replying to ignorant statements like yours is having no life, what’s wrong?.
The point is that you talk like you found out about the sitatuon of A7X + Mike days ago but didn’t you know that it was Mike saying here and there that he was going to be ”their rebound drummer” (or something like that).
I don’t need to ”chill out” because I’m not ”getting off trying to put people down for their own opinions”. I’ve read comments like ”I wish Mike would stay :(” and things like that and I didn’t reply anything because THOSE are opinions. Your comment, along with Tanner’s, are just ”A7X is so wrong. Mike Portnoy was a must. They are so wrong in this.”, or my favorite ”It seemed like Mike wanted to stay and they just threw him out”.
Had he wanted to stay, well he has a mouth, doesn’t he? He can talk and tell them and if they didn’t want him there well they didn’t and that’s it. No need to comments like ”Oh, that’s their biggest mistake ever, HOW COULD THEY LET HIM GO”, cause it means you don’t even know the band enough to realize that they NEVER said that he was permanent.
Like it now?
naww not really man..i never once said that A7X is wrong or that MP was a must..get your facts straight before you decide to post..i feel like im beating a dead horse talking to you about this because your the type of person who is always rite..It was my opinion that Mike was the best replacement for the Rev, that it and all i was doing was expressing my feelings just like everyone else is on this page.
I honestly dont wanna go into anything else cuz i know your gonna post something saying something to contradict something i said, which again goes back to the line where i said you have no life. Im not asking you to explain anything but from all the comments you wrote putting down peoples opinions just makes me wonder how much time a day you spend on deathbatnews. go ahead and write something else on my post..i love haters!
Comment by Joshua F December 19, 2010 @ 10:39 pmOk. Resuming:
Comment by Loghen December 20, 2010 @ 11:58 amI’m a hater of what??
You should read all the things that you write before making it publish…
And stop acting like “I’m smarter than you. It was my opinion. But i’m not like you. Reply whatever you want. It means you have no life..”
Do you seriously think that makes you look brighter than me?
I replied to you my opinion about your opinion, which was nowhere an offense, and all you do is act like “Look at the way I use my words. I’m better than you. It’s my opinion but please keep replying…”
its just funny cuz im getting a rise out of u…if u wanna end this then dont comment back on this..find someone else to annoy
Comment by Joshua F December 20, 2010 @ 2:04 pmlisten man..forget that last reply..we both are here because we love A7X and because we are effected by Jimmy’s passing..i dont wanna come up on DBN and talk fights with people just because of a difference of opinion
The only reason why i started in on you was because i took a lot of time, thought and emotion on the first post, and then i read your comment which basically bashed everything i said..its one thing to disagree but its another thing to quote almost every single line and explain why you think its wrong..that the only reason why i got angry. I wanna squash this right now..we both are fans..just with different opinions..Ive accpeted the MP departure..just wish it was different..we can all move on now..WE JUST NEED TO KNOW THAT IT ISNT ABOUT US ITS ABOUT A7X AND JIMMY’S MEMORY..im sorry to you Loghen and i hope that you accept..but heres something that i think you will appreciate..
“DEAR GOD” may Jimmy The Rev Sullivan rest in peace..its a shame how “I WONT SEE YOU TONIGHT” and how your life was “ALMOST EASY”..let him lay in “ETERNAL REST” and may his soul find that great “AFTERLIFE”..I was sad how in a “FLASH OF A BLADE” he was taken from us..let us bow our heads in silence and remember how Jimmy brought us all “THE CITY OF EVIL” in our hearts and the “UNHOLY CONFESSIONS” we love O so very much..R.I.P the best drummer in the world Jimmy the Rev Sullivan…we all love and miss you..spread your wings and fly freely man..A7X
Comment by Joshua F December 20, 2010 @ 2:32 pmOk. I’m sorry if my post offended you. I apologize and thank you for being such a mature person :).
Comment by Loghen December 20, 2010 @ 5:35 pm& I liked that last thing btw.
….Haven’t you read the tons of other comments concerning the reason why we shouldn’t be complaining that A7X is moving on without Mike…?
Comment by Alyssa December 18, 2010 @ 4:12 pmyea! its called an opinion! sorry mine doesnt agree with yours!
Comment by Joshua F December 19, 2010 @ 7:35 pmMike did really really well filling in and drumming in Jimmy’s style, because that was what he was asked to do. If the guys are looking to the future and the future of the band, if they’re even thinking about writing new music, they need to have someone that fits their music, their style, their attitude. I don’t know Mike and his other drumming, but something tells me he won’t be happy copying Jimmy’s drumming for good. The man is a musician and he is going to want to do his own style as well, and what if that style doesn’t work with the direction Avenged wants to go? The guys have a plan, and they know what works for their music. The fans may be very important to them (we are a family afterall), but first and foremost is the music that brought us together. They have to put their music first, their fans second and everything else beyond when it comes to the band. Mike must not have been the right fit for them or they would have probably tried to keep him longer.
I personally don’t think this is a mistake, it sounds like they’ve found someone that they’re willing to give a chance and see what happens, it means they’re healing and working to move on with their lives, with their music, and with us. I can’t see how that is a mistake, even if we don’t understand why they’ve chosen to part ways with Mike instead of try and keep him. We did know the day would come when they would move on to someone else, Mike even said he was their rebound drummer until they were ready to go steady with someone else. Maybe now is the time that they’re ready to go steady. That makes me a little nervous, but a lot excited for what they have in store for us. I think they just understood that they couldn’t continue to ask Mike to restrict his drumming to Avenged and Jimmy style when he’s got a lot more he wants to do. It would be like asking Picasso to paint only in Goya’s style (only grabbed two painters names of two different styles not saying one is really Picasso and the other Goya or anything). Both men are artists, both men create their own masterpieces, but you can’t ask someone to constantly copy the style of someone else and not expect them to want to break out and away from the constraint. Perhaps thats something Avenged took into consideration.
Just a thought. :)
Comment by Elin December 18, 2010 @ 4:23 pmtotally understandable..i just really liked mike and how he embraced the fans at the 2 shows i went to. Mike is gone its already said and done. i just hope that the new drummer is willing to fit Jimmy’s style also because i think no matter who is their drummer, they are going to have to drum like Jimmy or else it wont work out, just like with Mike.
Comment by Joshua F December 19, 2010 @ 7:39 pmI liked Mike and how he was at the two shows I was at as well. I thought he fit well and we all welcomed him. Whoever the new drummer is, yeah, they’re going to need to be able to fit Jimmy’s style, but if they are gonna be more long term and for new music, maybe their style fits Jimmy’s and Avenged’s and they won’t be restricting themselves. Only time will tell, but I trust the guys to find someone who works. :)
Comment by Elin December 20, 2010 @ 6:19 amyea definitely..MP just kicked ass..i just love how humble he was..and i just really liked how he embraced the Rev’s style..it just looked like it came natural to him, but yes like you said time will only tell..im definitely looking forward to the Nightmare after Christmas tour to see what they have in store for us
Comment by Joshua F December 20, 2010 @ 11:12 amYeah, I’m definitely looking forward to this tour. I’m skipping my dad’s birthday to go! Thankfully he understands. I’m hoping whoever they have taking up the kit, that their style falls in perfectly with Jimmy’s and Avenged’s without them having to change anything. And I hope they fall in with the band and the fans just as well as Mike did. Fingers crossed for an AMAZING Avenged year! 33 days till Lowell!
Comment by Elin December 20, 2010 @ 12:35 pmhell yea i cant wait either..im from california so im going to try to go to the boise idaho show and the eugene oregon show..super excited and nervous at the same time..but i love A7X so i know it will work out..i just wish they would play a show in Huntington Beach their home city cuz that would be epic and it would only take me like 20 mins to get there lol
Comment by Joshua F December 20, 2010 @ 2:08 pmI’m not totally sure about this, but is it that they’re doing shows they DIDN’T do on Uproar? Uproar skipped New England all together, and one of their dates is here. I’m not sure if thats the same with the rest of the dates, but the tour seems so short. I’m sure they’ll do another national tour soon and go back to Huntington Beach, they won’t forget their hometown when they do a full national tour I’m sure! I hope you get to the Boise show. I just wish I could do more than one!
Comment by Elin December 20, 2010 @ 5:52 pmThank you!!!!!!!!!!!! Finally a level headed person here.
Comment by Tanner December 18, 2010 @ 8:26 pmThey’re the most amazing human beings ever and I’ll support them with whatever they wanna do. It’s almost a year since jimmy died and it’s gonna be a hard day on the 28th but I still <3 them soooo much
Comment by Courtney December 18, 2010 @ 11:27 ami dont think that mike really fitted in this band so well and that´s why this is good news. i mean he is 43 years old and johnny is like 26..
Comment by jarmo December 18, 2010 @ 1:39 pmThe lead singer of INXS is 26 I believe and the rest of the band are in their late 40s early 50s I believe…age has nothing to do with it.
Comment by Marlz December 18, 2010 @ 10:36 pmLack of news today tbh lol Probs cos they arnt touring or nothing
Comment by Josh December 18, 2010 @ 2:11 pmI’m dieing to know who it is. I think Jimmy will be proud to see his best friends doing good. A7X Will continue with his legacy traveling with them and that is a beautiful thing.
Comment by Derek December 18, 2010 @ 3:28 pm[...] An Important Statement From Avenged Sevenfold To Fans. Avenged Sevenfold have released an important statement regarding Mike Portnoys departure and more to fans. For the [...] [...]
Pingback by Top Posts — WordPress.com December 18, 2010 @ 4:08 pmNews like this is really good for filtering out the “garbage” fans who pretend they like A7X way more than they really do.
Who are you all to judge whether this was a good decision or not? It is ultimately for the band to decide, and I am pretty sure they have more credibility for making such a heavy decision than you do.
And to the guy who said he lost a lot of respect for the band this year, I have one thing to say: get out. You sure as hell won’t be missed.
Comment by Zack December 18, 2010 @ 4:08 pmI second this. I see another jerk post something about losing respect and I am thankful they are gone. A7X deserves the most loyal, thankful fans and not bad mouthers who complain over EVERY move they make. Be glad they are sticking around…
Comment by Nikki V December 18, 2010 @ 5:41 pmhaha i didnt even think about it that way, thats a great point. one of the things i like best about our band and our fanbase is that we are a full-time family that loves unconditionally, not a bunch of part-timers who are ready to move on at any moment. thats why a7x is going to stick around for years.
Comment by Mark December 18, 2010 @ 6:57 pmI may get heat for this, but most of the fans doing the bad mouthing or saying they’ve lost respect have to be newbies. They are the ones who only recently starting following avenged. They love fiction or save me and have never heard of Sound of the Seventh Trumpet. They’ve never moshed to Unholy Confessions. That’s what so sucky about this whole thing. There are new fans who are now running their mouths and they are the part timer’s you’ve mentioned. The true fans are still here standing beside the boys no matter what. I just want to know how this go so nasty. We are all here for the same band. We should be standing up for them being trashed in the media. Why are we all turning against each other. This is the very reason the asked Mike to leave. D R A M A..
Comment by Nikki V December 18, 2010 @ 7:16 pmcompared to most of you guys im a newbie, ive only been listening to avenged for about a year and a half, but ive put my heart and soul into them for that year and a half and i dont see myself ever turning my back on them. i dont think its really about how long someone has been a fan but how loyal they are once they become a fan. i see your point though, these people who are throwing a shitfit are people that only superficially care about a7x, not fully committed.
Comment by Mark December 18, 2010 @ 8:31 pm2,5 years for me, the first and only band I’ve liked this long :)I agree with you guys, I’m supporting the guys all the way and I’m really exited to see who the new drummer will be
Comment by RaZoR December 19, 2010 @ 5:05 pmI agree. Sounding the Seventh Trumpet would make a lot of the MTV fans running to their mommies in tears. Though You have to respect the new fans too because they help the band live their dream of performing around the world. But ya a7x fan from 2002. Second Heartbeat still my favorite song, and they didn’t play it in vegas this year! Hah still was an awesome show. Whomever they choose will be majorly talented, which is why I am not worried. Though it would be nice if everyone gets off each others throats and just support the band in whatever they do.
Comment by Nick C December 18, 2010 @ 9:15 pmCouldn’t agree more! I support the band 100%. I started liking A7X right after WtF came out, and immediately fell in love (No homo). If they think Portnoy should go.. then I’m totally cool with it. Do I think he was a decent fit? Sure. But he’d far from sit back and just do the drum parts, he’d likely try and take over everything he could, and I think the guys saw that.
There’s really not a huge point in arguing about any of this. Their decision is their decision :)
Comment by Z.Burns December 18, 2010 @ 10:03 pmI support the band’s decision 100% I think it’s a great idea to part ways now instead of next year because it kind of forces them to move on and figure out their next move as a band.
I think Mike fit well with the band as a person. He was easily welcomed in with open arms for all that he had done. I am disappointed to see him go but it’s all for the best. His style of playing is different than A7X’s style. If he were on permanently, he would end up wanting to write material as well. As interesting as a more progressive Avenged Sevenfold might sound, it just wouldn’t be the same. So it’s good that they’re moving on and looking for someone that fits with them more.
Personally, I would love to see one of their VERY close friends take up the kit. They should get the Berry brothers to start taking drum lessons haha.
Also, as I was reading through all of these comments I realized how nasty some of us fans can be. I apologize to all of those that left a simple harmless opinion only to be verbally attacked. We are a very passionate family, but I do think we can handle things a little better. Let’s welcome newcomers to the family with a little less hostility :)
Comment by Steve December 18, 2010 @ 6:34 pmeverything that you want to do..
Comment by mery_coy December 18, 2010 @ 7:58 pmI belive it’s the best,,, :D
foREVer I’ll support..
To all those saying that it will always be ‘A7X and some drummer dude’ it won’t always be that way. Think of the biggest rock band ever… ACDC. Bon Scott died, and the new singer came on board, and they’re still as big as ever. People don’t think of the band as ACDC and some singer dude.[Granted there are some who think the band was better back when Bon was alive...] but it’s the same deal with A7X, Jimmy has passed and no one will be able to replace him ever, but if and when they decide to get a permanent drummer…and IF they don’t go the route of changing band name…the drummer will become part of A7X.
Comment by Marlz December 18, 2010 @ 10:47 pmHey you guys need to chill yo. Take a chillpill. Changes are bound to happen so please take everything with a pinch of salt. They can’t please everybody, so you can either like it or trash it but you must respect them. They are the one who rule their band, not you not MP. & all this exchange of words, is that all of these even necessary? Please bear in mind that we are only their fans, nothing more so they don’t even know of all of your existence. They have went through so much this year, just give them a break. Let’s show them our undying support instead.
Comment by Wirr December 19, 2010 @ 1:28 amI think we can’t complain at all. We should be very grateful that they will continue and that they’re seriously finding a fulltime drummer. Mike was obviously never supposed to stay with them forever.. and he has his own style that doesn’t fit A7X. I would understand that you guys would be disappointed if they would quit, but we have no reason to bitchfight over their decision because this is all we ever wished for: they’re not quitting!
Comment by Inge December 19, 2010 @ 4:30 amI disagree with A7X here, Mike was a good fit and would have worked well with the band. Clearly he wanted to continue, and the fans agreed. I just seems that A7X want to make it by themselves and not be the band that works with MP. Seems a little bit selfish.
Comment by Owen.C December 19, 2010 @ 10:34 ampretty sure it’s their band and they can do whatever they sit fit with whats best for them. mike, nor the fans, have any sort of say so in that. theyre entitled to make whatever decision they want. i dont know how that’s so hard to understand for some of you.
Comment by jon December 19, 2010 @ 10:39 amI didn’t say I was going on a crusade to stop them! I just don’t fully agree with them.
Comment by Owen.C December 20, 2010 @ 3:31 pmHow exactly does it seem selfish to not want to ride on mikes coattails? Also, Mike is used to being a leader of a band and running damn near everything, what do you think would end up happening if he permanently joined avenged? It isn’t selfish at all, they want to be their own band and maybe even give a lesser known drummer that is just as talented a shot. I see nothing wrong with that. Also, they didn’t change any plans, nor did they “boot” mike out. They stuck with the original plan and are taking the next ”baby step” forward which has been what they have said from the start.
Comment by Nick C December 19, 2010 @ 10:47 amIt feels selfish because, Mike AND the fans were very happy to continue. Now they decide they don’t want him because they want to do it on there own. They should put their ego behind them and continue to make awesome music.
If they don’t want Mike in the band because they don’t feel he fits then okay. But saying it’s because they want to do it against the odds on their own, IS selfish IMO.
Comment by Owen.C December 20, 2010 @ 3:34 pm“seems that A7X want to make it by themselves… Seems a little bit selfish”
Comment by Loghen December 19, 2010 @ 12:47 pmWTF?
They were doing it by themselves. They made this band. Just because they’re not kissing Mike’s balls, they are selfish?
Since when did you become a fan or started visiting this page? Yesterday?
This was the initial plan. Touring until they found a new drummer. They did, and now they’re selfish?
Lol. I can’t…
They weren’t kissing Mike balls. They recording an album and touring with him. It feels that they have fulfilled the Revs wishes and have now got bored of doing that.
We all knew that initial plan was so nobody felt tied in or had anything to uphold, however it became apparent that they would continue. Mike and the fans knew this and now they decide to do something else. That’s unwanted.
Comment by Owen.C December 20, 2010 @ 3:37 pmYes. But don’t you think that they can make good music without him anyway?
Comment by Loghen December 20, 2010 @ 5:28 pmThey thanked him every time they could. And yes, fans liked it, Mike liked it, the band liked it, but they knew having MP with them would be refflected on their music a lot, because Mike is not only a drummer and the man does a lot of stuff. Plus like I’ve said, he wouldn’t be playing Jimmy’s style forever. IMO it’s amazing what he did but I’m glad it’s over. People needs to know them as Avenged Sevenfold with whoever they like and trust as their drummer, not as the band that the well-known Mr. Mike Portnoy drums for.
i only ever gave a7x a chance cause of portnoy, i always heard of them from my kid and lil cousins and shrugged them off thinking they where a emo shit band. But hearing portnoy was playing on theyre new album and hearing him talk about theyre back story i thought id check em out and holy shit balls has my life turned into an a7x marathon/addiction wich would never in a million years happened if mp didnt help them out, in saying this ive sold my ticket to soundwave and am actually happy they arnt playing there i think an arena tour is more in order for them they could easily sell out acer arena in sydney with the right line up…….. im bummed portnoy isnt with em but who really couldnt see this coming really music is music yeah the a7x family is a family but ur all forgetting wat it was that brought u to the family in the first place
Comment by scott December 19, 2010 @ 3:34 pmTHE MUSIC, use r all very protective of this band and i find myself as a 30 year old australian man being the same but i never forget the most important thing THE MUSIC i hope u all dont get lost in all the drama put the cd on and smile and have a very merry xmas and new year much respect scott from sydney
Wanna know what I think? Chat with me on xbox live right now and I’ll tell you (it’s not bad lol) GT- somerandomguy25
Comment by Andrew December 19, 2010 @ 5:40 pmI promise I will not do it again.
Comment by Loghen December 19, 2010 @ 8:23 pmThis really did catch me by great suprise, Mike was saying he didnt know what was going to happen, and a7x were saying the same thing. Even though the plan was to move on, I could have sworn avenged was just waiting for the chance to be like “soooooo…mike…ever think about doing this permanently?” and i was just staying clutched until he said yay or nay. But he has talked alot like he was planning on staying. But when i heard it was the other way around, i felt kind of sad for mike, but was just overly shocked that a7x made the decision. It was a very mature move and agree that it will be best for the band, i just never saw it unfolding like this, cant wait to here the mystery drummer.
Comment by theo December 20, 2010 @ 7:18 amOkay,I’ve Been Reading A Couple Of Comments & Its Sad To See That We Are Fighting Against Each Other & Saying Things Like “The Guys Should Have Kept Mike” Or “This Is Such A Bad Decision”. We Are A Family Of LOYAL Fans, & Instead Of Fighting, We Should Be Supporting The Decision The Guys Made. Ever Since They Did The Album, Since They Began Touring, They Have Been Saying Mike Was Only Going To Stay With Them Till 2010. I Feel (This Is Just What I Think) That People Believed The Guys Were Going To Ask Mike To Stay With Them Just Because He & DT Aren’t Together Anymore. Avenged Didn’t Want To Create More Controversy Between Them & DT Fans. Like I’ve Said Before, I Have Been A Fan Since I Was 10, I’m 16 Now & Every Decision They Have Ever Made Was To Benefit Not Only Them, But Us Fans As Well. One Of The Many Reasons Why I Love This Band Is When They Do Make Decisions, They Want To Make Sure The Deathbat Family Is In The Same Page As They Are. They Consider Us In These Difficult Decisions & Personally, That’s Incredibly Humble. What Other Band Thinks The Way They Do? We All Should Stop Bashing Against Each Other & Just Look Towards The Future Of A7X & The Family.
Comment by Manny December 20, 2010 @ 11:43 amUPDATE: Recently Mike posted a message on his website saying that he tried to make amends with Dream Theater, who declined (actually their lawyer declined. No members of DT spoke with Mike). This would explain his “Mike Portnoy is sad :(…” message. He also stated he is not seeking sympathy or media attention. He is currently recording with Steve Morse.
I would like to apologize for jumping to conclusions and blaming this on Avenged Sevenfold.
Comment by Tanner December 20, 2010 @ 3:41 pmAs much as I love MP.
Without him, we never had this much negativity and arguments.
New guy will need to earn my respect. Jimmy and Mike are big shadows.
foREVer
Comment by Ryan'O December 20, 2010 @ 8:15 pmEveryone here must have forgotten that no matter what decision was made, it was all for Jimmy.. You have people here giving opinions (not a bad thing) but is not really needed, all we have to do is wait, see this new drummer and THEN give our honest opinion. Mike has his problems, so just let him be, he knows what he’s doing as well as A7x. If you dislike A7x with there decisions and new drummer in the future, then stop listening to them and find another band to your liking.
Comment by Anonymous December 22, 2010 @ 11:46 pmwow, its now 1 year ago. In this last year i’ve not only begun to know the band, but listened to their music, been at their concert and become a member of the A7x family :) I agree that noone can fully replace Jimmy, but that someone should substitude him in the best way possible. . So i’m really looking forward to seeing the new drummer, possibly the new member :) peace and love from Dk(ps: sorry for the spelling mistakes ;P)
Comment by Martin Mariboe December 26, 2010 @ 3:33 pm…and I guess in a maximum of three days we’ll know who the new drummer is.
Comment by Ultan January 17, 2011 @ 12:36 pmU serious? :D i’m sooo looking forward to it :P
Comment by Martin Mariboe January 18, 2011 @ 11:13 amI’m kinda curious as to why they’re keeping it hush till the last second. Either way, I’m seeing them Saturday and can’t wait!
Comment by Elin January 18, 2011 @ 12:48 pm